Sandwiches in Rio Rancho

Pressed subs and deli sandwiches at Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc in Rio Rancho, NM are available for pickup with meat-and-cheese fillings.

Order online

Popular Sandwiches to Try

Southwest Panini Sub

$9.50+

Turkey, banana peppers, onions, and chipotle sauce, pressed and toasted.

“Superb bagels... all the sandwiches are great! Very personable service.”

New Yorker Sub

$9.50+

Four meats and provolone top this sub with lettuce, tomato, and dressing.

“I got a New Yorker and it was delicious! I got the regular and it was much bigger than I expected. Bread was delicious, meats and veggies were so dang good. Customer service was great, legitimately such a friendly staff! I will be back again!”

Turkey Sub

$8.50+

Sliced turkey, provolone, mayonnaise, and vegetables in a sub.

“Delicious! I had the Turkey sub and it’s way better than any chain sandwich shop! Thank you!”

At the Heart of Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc

Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc serves sandwiches with sliced turkey breast, BBQ pulled pork or steak fillings. Children's choices include creamy peanut butter with grape jelly and grilled cheese with chips.

Tuna Sub pairs tuna with mayonnaise and banana peppers. Combo Sub layers ham, salami and provolone with Italian dressing. Chicken Parm Sub has oven-roasted chicken, marinara and mozzarella.

Visit us in Rio Rancho, NM for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Reuben combines NY pastrami, Swiss, Thousand Island and sauerkraut, pressed and toasted on marble rye; you can add avocado or green chile.

Sandwiches to Try

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich

$9.00

Bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich on your choice of bread.

“Excellent sandwiches piled high with meats. This is my 4 visit as I'm currently working my way through the menu. Excellent Reubens with quality cuts, super solid Cubanos, and pulled pork, too. I will post again in 6 months as I tackle some more subs.”

Chicken Club Sub

$9.50

Toasted chicken sub with bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and house dressing.

“Good Ruben sandwich Good chicken club”

Chicken Parm Sub

$9.50

Oven-toasted sub with chicken breast, marinara sauce and mozzarella.

“I Got The Philly Cheese Steak And My Girlfriend Got The Chicken Parmesan And It Was Worth The 5 Stars It Was Our First Time An It Was Very VERY.!! Delicious Definitely Gotta Go Again.”

Combo Sub

$8.50+

Ham, salami and provolone sub with vegetables and Italian dressing.

“The bread for the sandwiches holds up excellent through the dressings and deli cuts with good flavor”

Ham and Cheese Sub

$8.50+

Ham and provolone sub with vegetables and Italian dressing.

“I’m from New York and didn’t know I could get a sub this good in NM. I had the Turkey sub, the bread was excellent and it had the perfect amount of oil/vinegar. Seriously one of the best subs I have had.”

Kid's: Grilled Cheese

$6.75

Grilled white American and provolone cheese sandwich with chips.

“This place has become my new go to for subs in RioRancho. Definitely worth the visit. They make killer samiches.”

Kid's: Ham & Cheese

$6.75

Ham and cheese sandwich with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and chips.

“Born and raised in NY, these bagels and cc are the real deal. Freshly made everyday authentic boiled bagels. Run, don't walk here. We also had sandwiches that were amazing. Breads are fresh baked and meats are roasted in house. A great taste of home on NM.”

Kid's: Turkey & Cheese

$6.75

Turkey-cheese sandwich with lettuce, tomato, mayo, chips and bread choice.

“The best sandwiches around. All of them are great. Can't have just one favorite. The staff always is so nice”

Philly Steak & Cheese Sub

$9.50+

Beef, sautéed onions, mushrooms, peppers, and two cheeses.

“I ordered the Philly steak & cheese online. It was ready before the designated time. The meat was tender & tasty,the roll was soft & delicious . They definitely didn't skimp on the meat portions either. I will definitely be returning to try other subs. The gentleman that helped me was polite & courtesy. A big thumbs up for this restaurant!”

Reuben

$15.75

Pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut and Thousand Island pressed on marble rye.

“I ordered the Rueben and it was AMAZING! I don't live close to this place but I will definitely be back again!”

Roast Beef Sub

$8.50+

Roast beef sub with provolone, vegetables and Italian dressing.

“Can't stop coming here for the roast beef sandwich. Best tasting ever! Chips & pickles too!!”

Smokey Pig Sub

$9.50+

Pulled pork, bacon, provolone, and vegetables make up this sub.

“It's a small locally owned sandwich shop that makes the best sandwiches I've ever had. The staff are friendly, and it's never taken more than 5 minutes to get my order.”

Smokey Pig Supreme Sub

$9.50+

Sub with barbecue pulled pork, bacon, vegetables and provolone cheese.

“This is the best sandwich shop in Rio Rancho/Albuquerque stop in to try it for the first time with my wife we both enjoyed are meals from the bread with that tough exterior soft interior to the meat it comes with the pulled pork was nice with the sweet BBQ sauce crunchy bacon lettuce tomato and provolone excellent We will be back”

Tuna Sub

$8.50+

Tuna, mayonnaise, provolone, and crisp vegetables fill this sub.

“This family owned business is absolutely phenomenal! I love their bagels, sandwiches, and their brownies.”

Turkey Bomb Sub

$9.50+

Hot turkey sub with provolone, bacon, jalapeños and green chile.

“Best sandwich I've had in the Albuquerque area! The bread, meat and house dressing were excellent (I had the turkey bomb). Can't wait to try more! So delicious!”

Cubano

$9.50+

Pulled pork, ham, Swiss, onions, pickles and mustard fill this sub.

“I went in a couple of weeks ago to finally try this place. I’ve done some deliveries for grubhub from here and have been wanting to try it. I got the cubano and it was the best cubano I’ve had! The bread was perfectly crispy and soft and the meat inside was juicy and flavorful”

Deluxe Club

$9.50+

Ham, turkey, bacon, provolone, and vegetables on a sub roll.

“Nice place for subs! Great classic club! Couldn't eat the whole thing! Yummy!”

Fire In The Hole Sub

$9.50+

Steak, provolone, jalapeños, and chipotle sauce make a spicy sub.

“Best sandwiches, everything is amazing. Thank you for outstanding food.”

Kid's: PB&J

$6.75

Peanut butter and Welch's grape jelly sandwich, served with chips.

“This is my go to sandwich spot! They are the best in Rio Rancho! Super friendly people and amazing food.”

Kid's: Salami & Cheese

$6.75

Salami sandwich with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and a side of chips.

“This is the kind of place that you come back to over and over! Great menu, fantastic sandwiches. Highly recommend!”

Lorrice's Cuban Sub

$9.50+

Pulled pork, provolone, chipotle sauce, and onions, pressed hot.

“Cuban sandwiches are the best!”

Rebel Cuban Sub

$9.50+

Pressed sandwich with BBQ pork, ham, salami, provolone and pickles.

“Found my new spot! The NewYorker and Cubano sandwiches are my go to! Tried the bbq rebel it was super tasty! A must try!!”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Southwest Panini Sub — This toasted sub has turkey, banana peppers, onions, and homemade chipotle sauce; choose regular or 14-inch size.
New Yorker Sub — Ham, salami, capicola, and pepperoni come with provolone, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, peppers, and dressing; choose regular or 14-inch Big Boy.
Turkey Sub — Sliced turkey breast with provolone, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and banana peppers; choose regular or Big Boy size.
Philly Steak & Cheese Sub — Tender beef is served with sautéed onions, mushrooms, peppers, American cheese, and provolone; choose regular or 14-inch size.
Reuben — New York pastrami, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Thousand Island dressing are pressed and toasted on marble rye bread.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Rio Rancho area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc offers kid-friendly options, including Kid's: Grilled Cheese and Kid's: Salami & Cheese.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.