Sandwiches in Rio Rancho

Explore a full menu of sandwiches at Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc in Rio Rancho, NM, available for convenient pickup.

Order online

Popular Sandwiches to Try

New Yorker Sub

$9.50+

New Yorker Sub combines ham, salami, capicola, provolone, and vegetables.

“Bagels are incredible. Loved the New Yorker! Cannot wait to try the Cubans.”

Southwest Panini Sub

$9.50+

Toasted sub with turkey, peppers, onions, and chipotle sauce, pressed hot.

“We came in for the first time and it was at the end of the day so all their sub bread had sold out already. It was no problem at all as the staff offered to make whatever sub we wanted on any of the bagels they had left. The staff were very gracious even though they were just about ready to close for the day when we walked in. We had been craving real deli sandwiches and we were very happy with our food. We can’t wait to go back to try their sub bread too.”

Turkey Bomb Sub

$9.50+

A hot turkey sub includes provolone, bacon, jalapeños, and green chili.

“Alicia's is always great! Best subs in Rio Rancho.”

Prepared the Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc Way

Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc in Rio Rancho, NM serves a wide-ranging sandwiches menu, from classic cold cuts to bold signature subs built for every appetite.

Fan favorites include the Philly Steak & Cheese Sub, New Yorker Sub, Reuben, Smokey Pig Supreme Sub, Turkey Sub, and the Lorrice's Cuban Sub, each packed with distinct flavors.

Visit Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc in Rio Rancho, NM and enjoy your sandwiches your way—whether you prefer dine-in, pickup, or delivery to your door.

Sandwiches to Try

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich

$9.00

Bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich on your choice of toast.

“Best subs and bagels in all of New Mexico, hop in the car and go 👍”

Chicken Club Sub

$9.50

Roasted chicken, bacon, and vegetables fill a pressed, toasted sub.

“Good Ruben sandwich Good chicken club”

Chicken Parm Sub

$9.50

Toasted chicken sub with marinara and melted mozzarella cheese.

“The best sandwiches around. All of them are great. Can't have just one favorite. The staff always is so nice”

Combo Sub

$8.50+

Ham-salami sub with provolone, pickles, peppers, vegetables, and dressing.

“Best sandwiches, everything is amazing. Thank you for outstanding food.”

Ham and Cheese Sub

$8.50+

Ham-provolone sub with lettuce, pickles, peppers, tomatoes, and dressing.

“It's a small locally owned sandwich shop that makes the best sandwiches I've ever had. The staff are friendly, and it's never taken more than 5 minutes to get my order.”

Kid's: Grilled Cheese

$6.75

Grilled white American and provolone cheese sandwich with chips.

“Delicious sandwiches every time. Love supporting local businesses 💜”

Kid's: Ham & Cheese

$6.75

Ham and cheese sandwich with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and chips.

“Great homemade sandwiches and subs. Tasty!”

Kid's: Pizza Bread

$6.75

Toasted sub-roll halves with marinara, provolone, and chips.

“Affordable, good food. Good customer service and not shy with the toppings on bagels or subs!”

Kid's: Turkey & Cheese

$6.75

Turkey-cheese sandwich with vegetables and chips on white or wheat bread.

“Superb bagels... all the sandwiches are great! Very personable service.”

Philly Steak & Cheese Sub

$9.50+

Steak sub with sautéed onions, mushrooms, peppers, and two cheeses.

“I ordered the Philly steak & cheese online. It was ready before the designated time. The meat was tender & tasty,the roll was soft & delicious . They definitely didn't skimp on the meat portions either. I will definitely be returning to try other subs. The gentleman that helped me was polite & courtesy. A big thumbs up for this restaurant!”

Reuben

$15.75

Pressed rye sandwich with pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island.

“I ordered the Rueben and it was AMAZING! I don't live close to this place but I will definitely be back again!”

Roast Beef Sub

$8.50+

Roast Beef Sub has roast beef, provolone, pickles, and Italian dressing.

“Can't stop coming here for the roast beef sandwich. Best tasting ever! Chips & pickles too!!”

Smokey Pig Sub

$9.50+

Pulled pork, bacon, and provolone fill this sub with lettuce and tomato.

“I’m from New York and didn’t know I could get a sub this good in NM. I had the Turkey sub, the bread was excellent and it had the perfect amount of oil/vinegar. Seriously one of the best subs I have had.”

Smokey Pig Supreme Sub

$9.50+

BBQ pulled pork, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and provolone fill this sub.

“This is the best sandwich shop in Rio Rancho/Albuquerque stop in to try it for the first time with my wife we both enjoyed are meals from the bread with that tough exterior soft interior to the meat it comes with the pulled pork was nice with the sweet BBQ sauce crunchy bacon lettuce tomato and provolone excellent We will be back”

Tuna Sub

$8.50+

Tuna sub with mayo, lettuce, tomato, pickles, peppers, and provolone.

“Best sandwich I've had in a LONG time, I came back to New Mexico to visit family and this was one of the big highlights. Thank you guys so much!!!”

Turkey Sub

$8.50+

Turkey sub with mayo, lettuce, tomato, pickles, peppers, and provolone.

“I tried Alicea's for the first time a month ago, and I have no idea why I waited so long!! Went back again today! The ham, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich was delicious. The service was amazing, and the food is made fresh. My mom had the turkey and provolone sandwich and she loved it. Great portions as well!”

Cubano

$9.50+

Cubano: pulled pork, ham, Swiss cheese, onions, pickles, and mustard.

“Soooooooo Delicious! You have the BEST Cubanos by far! Photo is after eating my half (I share with hubby).”

Deluxe Club

$9.50+

Club sandwich with ham, turkey, bacon, provolone, vegetables, and chips.

“Nice place for subs! Great classic club! Couldn't eat the whole thing! Yummy!”

Fire In The Hole Sub

$9.50+

Steak sub with provolone, jalapeños, vegetables, and chipotle sauce.

“This place has become my new go to for subs in RioRancho. Definitely worth the visit. They make killer samiches.”

Kid's: PB&J

$6.75

Kids’ peanut butter and Welch’s grape jelly sandwich with chips.

“I needed to cater 80 lunches for volunteers at an event & wanted to support a local business. I ordered from Alicea’s via the Ezcater.com site and the process was easy. On the day of the event, the owner & employees delivered the 80 lunches in-time and set them up in our break area. Many of our volunteers complimented the quality and taste of the sandwiches, which were delivered with cookies, chips, pickles, and condiments on the side. I will order from them again for our events. They were super helpful.”

Kid's: Salami & Cheese

$6.75

Kids’ salami and cheese sandwich with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and chips.

“Absolutely amazing bagels and sandwiches!”

Lorrice's Cuban Sub

$9.50+

Pressed sub with pulled pork, provolone, onions, and chipotle sauce.

“Gigantic sub. Super tasty. Relaxed sandwich spot. Fast and friendly service. Highly recommended!”

Rebel Cuban Sub

$9.50+

Pressed sandwich with pulled pork, ham, salami, Provolone, and pickles.

“Found my new spot! The NewYorker and Cubano sandwiches are my go to! Tried the bbq rebel it was super tasty! A must try!!”

Veggie Sub

$8.50+

A vegetable sandwich with greens, peppers, pickles, avocado, and provolone.

“I used to make sandwiches for a job and they make ones that are superb. Well priced and they fill you up. They have a wide variety and so far, they have all been delicious!!!”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

New Yorker Sub — This sub contains ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, provolone, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, peppers, and dressing.
Southwest Panini Sub — This pressed, toasted sandwich contains turkey, peppers, onions, and chipotle sauce for a warm, savory filling.
Turkey Bomb Sub — Turkey Bomb Sub is a hot sandwich with turkey, provolone, bacon, vegetables, mayonnaise, house dressing, and green chili.
Turkey Sub — This sandwich layers sliced turkey, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, pickles, banana peppers, and provolone cheese together.
Philly Steak & Cheese Sub — Tender beef, sautéed vegetables, American cheese, and provolone make up this classic steak sandwich filling.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Rio Rancho area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

Yes! Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc offers kid-friendly options, including Kid's: Grilled Cheese and Kid's: Salami & Cheese.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.